Boulder City Council voted 8-0 on Nov. 19 to approve a major redesign of the historic Glen Huntington Bandshell’s seating area, overturning an earlier decision by the city’s Landmarks Board to reject the changes.
Because the bandshell is a designated historic landmark, alterations to the site require historic preservation approval. The Landmarks Board rejected the proposal Sept. 2, but city council agreed Sept. 17 to review the decision. Thursday’s unanimous vote overturned the board’s ruling, clearing the way for the project to move forward.
“This additional investment in this area cements the location of the bandshell and its importance in the community,” Mayor Aaron Brockett said. “I feel like this is a refresh to the seating in a way that will be beneficial to future generations.
“But it also makes clear that the bandshell has a permanent place in the heart of Boulder for generations to come.”
The decision comes as the city’s Parks and Recreation Department faces difficult budget decisions. Several councilmembers acknowledged that the project could draw criticism, given the department’s budget cuts and the lack of identified funding to keep Spruce Pool open in 2028.
“I feel like that’s the right decision,” Mayor Pro Tem Tara Winer said. “But also, I feel like the community is going to really push back, considering that we’ve been talking about pools and emergencies to them, which this doesn’t seem like an emergency.”
Ali Rhodes, director of Parks and Recreation, told councilmembers the project is almost entirely funded through previously approved budgets.
The Glen Huntington Bandshell, built in 1938 in downtown Boulder’s Central Park, is one of only two remaining examples of early- to mid-20th-century Art Deco-style bandshells in Colorado. The landmark has long served as a gathering and performance space, including for the city’s annual Arts in the Park series.
The redesign is part of the city’s second phase of improvements to Boulder Creek Park, formerly known as the Civic Area.
The biggest change would replace 15 rows of sloped benches, installed in the 1950s, with five rows of terraced lawn and built-in concrete benches. The new design would preserve the existing seating area’s semicircular layout while allowing visitors to use portable chairs, picnic blankets and yoga mats.

The number of permanent seats would drop from 600 to 230, but the redesigned space could accommodate up to 686 people, including 18 designated wheelchair spaces, according to city estimates. The distance between the stage and seating would also shrink from 38 feet to 28 feet.
City staff say the changes would improve accessibility, offer more flexible seating and reduce long-term maintenance costs. Maintaining the current seating is projected to cost about $1.2 million over 25 years, or $48,000 annually, compared with $420,000 over the same period, or $16,800 annually, for the new seating. According to city staff, the existing seating would need to be replaced within five to 10 years if the redesign does not move forward.
Construction of the new seating is estimated to cost $313,000, included in the $420,000 projected cost. The construction cost represents roughly 1.7% of the Parks and Recreation Department’s budget.
The proposal also includes reconfigured pedestrian walkways and a nearby raised deck, mostly outside the landmark boundary, that could serve as an informal extension of the performance venue and a public gathering space.
No changes are proposed to the historic bandshell structure itself.
The proposal also drew support from Colorado Preservation Inc., a statewide historic preservation advocacy group, which argued that preserving the bandshell structure itself should be the priority.
“Proposed replacement seating would retain the scale, rhythm, and radial configuration of the historic seating, and planning has benefited from a thoughtful study of how historic outdoor theaters can accommodate change while retaining their defining character,” the organization wrote in a letter.
But members of the Landmarks Board argued that the existing seating is an integral part of the historic site. They also raised concerns about the loss of permanent seats, sight lines and how the redesign could affect future performances.
“My concern is that we’re proposing to demolish the wooden benches, a character-defining feature of its designated landmark, without exploring preservation alternatives,” said Renee Golobic, chair of the Landmarks Board. “Preservation should be a starting point of the design.”
Some community members also opposed the changes.
Leonard Segel, retired executive director of Historic Boulder Inc., said the concrete supports for the seats are largely intact and the seats themselves are historically significant.
“Promoting such a destructive change to the historic fabric of an official city landmark would act as a signal that owners of other landmarks in town could selectively destroy significant portions of their properties,” Segel told city council before the vote.
Segel has also questioned the project’s cost at a time when Boulder faces a budget shortfall. He raised concerns that continued vandalism could drive maintenance costs higher than the city projects.
